It's nearly book choosing time at book group, and each year I have to get my book choices in place. The group has been running for nearly 20 years and for the last 15 years we've had this interesting voting system which means very few 'bad' books get through. We've had the occasional stinker - often books so esoteric everybody gets put off (I'm thinking of JR Thorp's Lear Wife, which only those who listened to the audiobook begrudgingly liked it), too long (Amor Towles The Lincoln Highway at just over 600 pages is on this list) or just didn't cut the mustard (the one book I couldn't finish was Brendan Cowell's Plum - though others really liked it.)
Anyway, I get to vet the book choices, check for double ups (which always happen) and this year, I'm making sure the choices are under 500 pages, just to give the books a more even playing field.
Then I get to my long list, and I'm starting the cull.
Here's what I wish I could put up. And reasons why I can't.
1) The Weight of Angels by John Boyne
John Boyne is fast becoming a favourite author. His A Ladder to the Sky and The Heart's Invisible Furies are two of the best books I've read this year, and my mother has a copy of The Elements which I'll pick up at Christmas.
His latest book, The Weight of Angels, gives an alternate history of Oscar Wilde, where he didn't get sent to jail, rather, he lived into the 20th Century, rather than dying, destitute in Paris.
I adore Oscar Wilde. I adore John Boyne. But at 592 pages, I can't put this up. It's a pity. This promises to be amazing. It's currently got a 4.09 rating on GoodReads. I see this as a Christmas read. Unfortunately, its not for book group.
2) The Crimson Petal and the White by Michel Faber
I adore this book. Love it beyond measuare. The story of a prostitute in Victorian England and the coniving way she infiltrates a family. It's utterly brilliant. I loaned my copy out to somebody years ago on the proviso that it came back. It never did.I remember taking it on holiday to Bali one time and I was known at the girl with the big book around the resort. At the last retreat, somebody put it on the trading table - and I snapped it up, relieved to have it back.
But at nearly 900 pages, its never going to fly as a book group book. It's a superb book. I need another holiday where I can cart this around like a baby.
This is one of the best books I've read this year. Kate Atkinson is a British national treasure and this book is up there. The story of Ursula Todd and her family. In the words of TS Eliot, in a minute there is time for decisions and revisions that a minute will reverse."
This is a Sliding Doors kind of novel. Within the first few pages Ursula has died on numerous occasions. And like with Slaugherhouse Five, and so it goes, here darkness falls. The consequences of an action are interrogated. Sometimes Ursula lives, other times she doesn't. It is a remarkable book.
At 475 pages it does fit the book group criteria, but I think some of the themes and the book's unrelenting different structure will put a few people off.
But this book, and it's sequel, A God in Ruins are magnificent. Her lastest novel, Our Noble Selves is great too, highlighting the barking mad nature of the brits.
Kate Atkinson is worth the read.
The Time Traveller's Wife is one of those seminal books that came out in the early noughties that everybody read and loved. Life Out of Order is it's long awaited sequel, taking on the story of Alba, Claire and Henry's daughter from the first book.
The thing is, at 560 pages it's not getting through on the page count, but looking at Goodreads, there are lot of scathing reviews.
I'll leave this one for holiday reading.
Another one in the too long club. Andrew O'Hagan has been touted as the new, Scottish Jonathan Franzen, but at 638 pages, I can't put this up. O'Hagan is a joy to read - just not for book group.
I'm listening to this at the moment on audiobook and it is incredible. The story of a boy who falls out of a window into the Thames and his family's search for the truth and justice. The thing is, this kid was a confidence trickster, getting into bed with Russian oligarchs. It shows the seedy, unbelievable side of London we all know exists but never see.
This comes highly recommended. Unfortunately, as it's non-fiction it doesn't make the grade.
But read it - it's amazing.
We've read a lot of Elif Shafak in our book group over the years. There are Rivers in the Sky, here latest book, sits around the 450 pages makes this one of longer books. I read it earlier in the year and was amazed by it. It's glorious. It weaves a number of stories together, taking on a number of geopolitical themes, history, families, you name it, it's in there.
But it was put up last year for consideration and it didn't make the cut. I'm not going to chance it a second time. But it's fantastic.
As always, there are too many books to read, not enough time to read them. I could add a lot of books to this list, but this is the won't make it pile.
My search continues.






